Best italian food in Orange City

Your New York Neighborhood Style Pizzeria

Freshness Beyond Borders

Authentic New York Style Pizza

Authentic New York Style Pizza
Immerse yourself in the true essence of New York-style pizza. Our hand-tossed, thin-crust pizzas capture the spirit of the city that never sleeps, delivering that perfect combination of a crisp yet foldable slice.

Home of the Best Burgers in Town!

Home of the Best Burgers in Town!
Our pizza is the what we are known for, but our burger is one of the best kept neighborhood secrets! Delicious and expertly crafted - try one today!

Where Freshness Meets Flavor!

Where Freshness Meets Flavor!
At Blue Spring Pizza, we take pride in delivering a dining experience that begins with the finest, freshest ingredients. Our commitment to quality ensures that every dish is a celebration of flavor and a testament to the goodness of nature.
Order From Our Website

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.
Order Online

Featuring

Catering

Gluten-Free Options

Healthy Options

Easy Parking

Under New Management

Under New Management
Blue Springs Pizza is back, completely overhauled. Come dine-in with us, order take-out, or get it delivered!

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

Quality fresh ingredients prepared with a high level of excellence. One of the top restaurants in Orange City. I've tried many items on the menu well over 30 times of going there in a few month spand, and each time I have been completely satisfied with the food, service, atmosphere.

John D.

John D.

I ordered a pizza to go and went and picked it up The pizza was very good and I will be going back again soon. A good place to eat lunch. Nice atmosphere. Service was great

Jane D.

Jane D.

This is our 4th time coming here and every time has been a HIT!!! If you have not tried this place, it is a must do!!! Also our server Raven was amazing! She was fast, friendly, and very attentive! Ask for her when you go in!!

Tyler P.

Tyler P.

Blue Spring Pizza Rewards

Blue Spring Pizza Rewards

Join our rewards program to earn points, get free items, and stay up to date with us.
Join Our Rewards

Frequently asked questions

Our location